Holiday shoppers are easy. They show up drunk on novelty, waving their credit cards like glowsticks at a concert. But the real game? Keeping them interested after the tinsel’s down and the New Year’s dopamine crash kicks in. That’s where most beauty and fashion brands panic and throw another BOGO sale at the void. But if your customer engagement strategy begins and ends with a promo code, you’re not building a brand, you’re running a seasonal pop-up.

Turning seasonal spenders into loyalists isn't about seducing them once. It’s about making sure they never stop thinking about you. And if you play your loyalty cards right, you can trade cheap thrills for deep brand intimacy. Let’s get into it.

‍

Why they ghost you in January and how to make sure they don’t.

It’s not that holiday shoppers don’t like you. It’s that you never gave them a reason to stay. In fashion and beauty, where purchase decisions are emotional, aesthetic, and identity-driven, loyalty can’t be manufactured; it has to be earned.

Not with spammy post-holiday emails. Not with last-chance sales. But with actual, personality-rich customer engagement that makes them feel like part of the inner circle. The girls don’t want coupons; they want access. They want a wink. A whisper. A reason to open your email in March, even though they swore off spending in January.

Why Seasonal Customers Don’t Stick

If your brand’s post-holiday plan is to “email them later,” here’s what you’re up against:

1. They came for a gift, not for you.

Holiday shoppers are often buying for someone else; your job is to make them fall in love with you anyway.

2. There’s no next step.

If there's no welcome sequence, no personalized touch, no subtle “stay with me” energy, of course, they vanish.

3. You’re not building memory.

Brand loyalty relies on repetition and resonance. If your holiday pitch was all sparkle and no soul, they won’t remember you by February.

4. You chased conversions, not connections.

You seduced them with a discount, but didn’t leave them breathless with your vibe. Big mistake.

5. Your PR is one-dimensional.

If you only show up when you want to sell, you become noise. Loyalty is built in between the big launches, in your tone, your timing, your stories.

Sephora is the master of the long game. The Beauty Insider program isn’t just a loyalty scheme; it’s a full-blown parasocial relationship. You buy one lipstick in December, and suddenly you’re being seduced with exclusive drops, birthday gifts, and tiered status like you’ve joined some glittering cult.

Instead of dangling discounts post-holiday, Sephora nurtures long-term customer engagement with early access, personalized perks, and insider content that whispers you belong here. The point system is a mechanic, sure, but the real engine is emotional. It’s not just “shop more”, it’s “look how far you’ve come.” That’s the kind of brand loyalty that makes someone forget Ulta exists.

‍

Loyalty Tips That Actually Work (and don’t feel like a CVS receipt)

1. Build a Welcome Sequence with Bite
Don’t say “thanks for shopping.” Say “we’ve been waiting for someone like you.” Drip-feed your story, not your SKU list.

2. Turn Purchases Into Personality Tests
Recommend products that fit their energy, not just their cart. “Since you bought mascara, here’s a matching attitude.”

3. Use PR to Feed the Fantasy
Pitch stories that aren’t about what you sell, but who your customer becomes by choosing you. Make them the main character.

4. Create Off-Sale Moments
Host a Zoom skincare confession booth. Drop a private playlist. Offer something weird and wonderful that isn’t just another sale.

5. Tease Instead of Tell
Loyalty thrives on curiosity. Hint at what’s coming. Make them wonder what they’ll miss if they unsubscribe.

6. Tiered Status = Emotional Dopamine
Whether it’s “Hot,” “Hotter,” or “Who Gave Her a Black Card?”, status should feel like foreplay, not a spreadsheet.

Let’s Talk About the Real Flex: Long-Term Seduction

If someone buys from you once, it’s proof they want to feel something. Your job is to give them a reason to chase that feeling again. You don’t need more promotions. You need a better plotline. Think less CRM, more enemies-to-lovers arc.

PR is where you can really sharpen this story. The smartest brands aren’t just plugging products, they’re showing up in podcasts, in profiles, in features that reveal their backstage. They’re making noise between seasons so that when the next drop hits, you’re not starting from zero attention; you’ve been in their head all along.

Holiday shoppers are the gateway drug. But if you want long-term fans, stop treating them like one-night stands. Make them feel like insiders. Tease them with possibility. Reward them for sticking around. Seduce with your story, not your sale.

Book your strategy call → Let’s turn your seasonal spike into a year-long love affair.